Noisy secret of Mona Lisa's smile
For centuries, artists, historians and tourists have been fascinated by Mona Lisa's enigmatic smile. Now it seems that the power of Leonardo da Vinci's masterpiece comes in part from an unlikely source: random noise in our visual systems.
Christopher Tyler and Leonid Kontsevich at the Smith-Kettlewell Eye Research Institute in San Francisco manipulated a digital image of the painting by introducing random visual noise and asked 12 observers how they rated the resulting expression on a four-point scale from sad to happy.
As would be expected, noise that lifted the edges of her mouth made Mona Lisa seem happier, and those that flattened her lips made her seem sadder. More surprising though, was how readily the visual noise changed people's perception of the Mona Lisa's expression.
Tyler says our visual system contains many sources of noise: fluctuations in the number of photons hitting light-receiving cells in the eye, spontaneous false activation of photon absorbing pigments, and randomness in the firing of neurons that carry the visual signals to the brain.
Tyler thinks this natural noise makes people observing the picture believe its expression is subtly changing, rather than thinking they are seeing a single ambiguous expression.
"That may be part of what makes the painting so powerful," he says, something Leonardo must have instinctively realised.
Journal reference: Vision Research (vol 44, p 1493)
The Mona Lisa, Mc Guinness. Another possible reason for the Mona Lisa's smile! For a closer look at the The Mona Lisa Mc Guinness use the link below. - [154 kB]he Mona Lisa, Mc Punk. Another version of the Mona Lisa! For a closer look at the The Mona Lisa Mc Punk use the link below. - [349kB]
